Tony: rum raisin ice cream, he eats it from the carton
Natasha: dark chocolate
Steve: literally anything sweet because the Depression was not a great Sugar Eating Time and neither was the war
Thor: also literally anything sweet but he really likes novelty flavored ice cream because Asgard doesn’t have it
Clint:
cold pizzacoffee ice cream or that one potato chip ice cream from Ben and Jerry’sBruce: banana split
Bucky: hard candy, he likes to just tuck it in his cheek and keep it there
Sam: creme brulee with raspberries because it’s fancy looking and delicious
Wanda: some Sokovian dessert nobody can pronounce
T’Challa: chocolate lava cake with vanilla ice cream
Rhodey: fruit because he’s the one responsible adult person in this crew and no, Tony, he’s not eating your rum raisin ice cream not even a spoonful
Scott: oreo mcflurries